Skip to content
Home » What if My Medical Bills are Higher Than My Settlement Offer?

What if My Medical Bills are Higher Than My Settlement Offer?

An accident can lead to substantial medical bills. For example, a severe car accident can result in thousands of dollars of medical bills. Medical expenses are a significant component of a settlement. Unfortunately, sometimes insurance companies offer compensation that is not enough to cover the claimant’s medical expenses, let alone other damages. If you find yourself in a situation where the insurance company has made you a settlement offer that is less than your medical bills, you might not know what to do. This article discusses what to do if your medical bills are higher than your settlement offer.

Why Would You Receive a Low Settlement Offer?

Insurance companies are in the business of making profits. They often make offers much lower than the actual costs of a claimant’s medical bills and other losses to save money and protect their profits.

The liability insurance limits may also result in a victim receiving a low settlement offer. Regardless of how badly injured a victim is, the insurance company cannot pay more than the policy limits. For instance, if the liability policy only covers $20,000 and your bills are $40,000, the insurer is not obligated to offer more than the policy limit.

Another reason why you may receive a low settlement offer is if the at-fault party’s insurance company believes you were partially at fault for the accident. In comparative negligence states, compensation is usually reduced based on the plaintiff’s percentage of fault.

Steps to Take if You Receive a Low Settlement Offer

If the insurance company makes you a settlement offer that is less than your medical bills, here are steps you can take;

1.      Do Not Accept the Offer

If you accept a settlement offer from an insurance company and sign a release, you waive your right to seek more damages. For this reason, it is vital not to accept an inadequate offer without careful consideration or legal advice.

2.      Hire an Attorney

An experienced attorney can assess the fairness of the settlement offer, determine the full extent of your claim, and negotiate with the insurance company on your behalf. Insurance companies are usually willing to make fair settlement offers to plaintiffs with legal representatives. 

If the insurance company refuses to make a fair offer, an attorney can help you seek additional compensation from other sources, such as uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage and a personal injury lawsuit.

3.      Negotiate Medical Bills

With the help of an attorney, you can try negotiating with healthcare providers to reduce your medical bills. If you offer to pay a lump sum or demonstrate financial hardship, healthcare providers may be willing to lower your medical bills. Other options for working with providers to lower your medical bills include payment plans and charity care programs.  

4.      Gather and Organize Your Medical Records

Ensure you have detailed records of all your medical expenses, including prescriptions, hospital visits, and future treatment needs. This documentation can help support your claim and strengthen negotiations by clearly showing the extent of your medical costs.

Let Us Assist You

If you’re dealing with costly medical bills after an accident, The Stone Law Office can help you evaluate your options. We can handle all the legal procedures for you. Contact us today to schedule a consultation.


Discover more from Your personal injury is our business

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

1 thought on “What if My Medical Bills are Higher Than My Settlement Offer?”

  1. Pingback: Understanding Tax Implications of Car Accident Settlements - Case notes & legal briefs

Comments are closed.

CASE CONSULTATION REQUEST FORM

Were you or a loved one injured due to someone else’s negligence? Summarize what happened by filling out this form. Someone from our office will review your details and contact you for a free, no-obligation consultation to discuss your legal options. We commit to helping you get the justice and compensation you deserve.

Dallas (main ofc)

Address

2825 Oak Lawn Avenue Unit 190365
Dallas, Texas
75219

Call Us

Phone number: (214) 871-9000

Chicago Office

Address

16260 Louis Avenue Unit 321 Chicago, Illinois 60473 

Call Us

Phone number: (312) 499-3000

Charlotte Office

Our Address

3202 Wilkinson Blvd.
Charlotte, North Carolina
28208

Call Us

Phone number: (704) 940-9968

Small law office, big results.

Free case review

Multi-jurisdictional

Illinois, Texas and North Carolina Licensed

© 2025 The Stone Law Office. All Rights Reserved. DISCLAIMER: Choosing a lawyer is an important decision. Incorporate more than advertising into the decision. The information provided in this website by The Stone Law Office is not legal advice. The Stone Law Office requires a signed retainer with the firm to become a client. The information provided in this site is insufficient to create an attorney client relationship. The Stone Law Office achieved results identified in this site which were based on the facts and circumstances of the case described.

Discover more from Your personal injury is our business

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Candice

Candice

Typically replies within 3 minutes

I will be back soon

Candice
Hello.
Candice here.  Lets talk about your injury claim.  Tell me what happened?
WhatsApp